Winery HR: Top 5 Tips for Businesses Without a Dedicated HR Manager, with Jessica Hart
Jessica Hart grew up in Sonoma County, went to college with zero intention of working in HR, and ended up in her first real class on labor law realizing she had personally been underpaid by an employer who had not set up overtime correctly. That experience, navigating a payroll conversation no employee should have to navigate alone, is what pulled her into the field. She went on to build HR programs at Target during a period of rapid expansion across California, then joined Heineken and Lagunitas through a major post-merger integration, working across multiple states and cultures. Now she runs Jessica Hart Consulting, focused on supporting small and mid-sized wine and food businesses that are held to the same labor laws as large corporations but do not have anywhere near the same internal resources.
She sat down with Lauren Heindel to share the five most important HR foundations for wineries operating without a dedicated HR person. The conversation is direct, practical, and grounded in the realities of winery production — not corporate policy.
Here is the honest tension at the center of winery HR: small producers are subject to the same state and federal labor laws as large employers, but they rarely have the infrastructure to keep up with them. The result is not malicious — most winery owners are not trying to underpay their staff or skip break policies — it is that the laws are dense, constantly changing, and written without any regard for how a production winery actually operates.
In this episode, we cover:
Why pay and compensation laws in California are more specific than most winery owners realize, including meal premiums and the difference between tipped minimum wage and standard minimum wage
What BYOD (bring your own device) policies are and why your winery likely owes employees reimbursement if they use their personal phones for work
Why your employee handbook matters for legal compliance, and a practical approach using QR codes that keeps it accessible and current
How winery managers can document coaching conversations without formal paperwork, and why a text message is enough
What a responsible consumption policy covers, both for guest-facing tasting room staff and for cellar and production employees
Tip 1: Get your pay and compensation structure right
Pay and compensation is where the largest compliance exposure lives for most wineries, and it is where the rules are most likely to surprise owners who have not reviewed them recently.
Jessica starts here every time because the consequences of getting it wrong are immediate and financial. In California, there are two layers of minimum wage to keep track of: the state minimum and the city minimum, which in some municipalities is higher. If you have a tasting room with a tip line, those tips need to be properly reported and factored into payroll taxes. None of this is optional.
The area that catches winery owners most off-guard is meal premiums. In California, if an employee works more than six hours in a day, they must take a 30-minute uninterrupted lunch break before their fifth consecutive hour of work. Uninterrupted means not receiving texts from the manager, not carrying a walkie-talkie, not being reachable for work purposes at all. If that break does not happen, the employer owes the employee one additional hour of pay, called a meal premium.
If they can't clock out by that fifth consecutive hour, you now owe them what's called a meal premium. It's the state saying, hey, don't be a jerk employer.
Jessica Hart , Owner
Jessica Hart Consulting
Jessica is equally direct about a shortcut many owners reach for: converting employees to salaried status to avoid tracking hours. Being salaried is not a general-purpose workaround. There are specific legal criteria for what qualifies as an exempt salaried position, and putting someone on salary who does not meet those criteria does not protect you from overtime obligations — it just makes them harder to track.
If you have employees in a tasting room receiving tips and you operate in a state with a tipped minimum wage (common outside California), make sure your payroll software is actually applying tip credits correctly. If an employee does not claim enough tips to bring them to the regular minimum wage, you are required to make up the difference. This is a common area where payroll systems fail small businesses quietly.
Tip 2: Have a clear policy on personal device use
Most winery employees use their personal phones for at least some aspect of their job: clocking in and out through a mobile app, receiving work texts, checking a shared calendar, or responding to scheduling messages after hours. In California and several other states, that use creates a legal obligation for the employer to reimburse employees for a reasonable portion of their personal phone costs.
This is not a gray area. If you require an employee to download an app, respond to work messages, or use their phone in any work-related capacity, you owe them a stipend or reimbursement. The exact amount is not fixed by law, but “nothing” is not an acceptable answer.
If you have your employee clock in and clock out on their phone, or you require them to download an app so that they can email you — in California, you have to have a line item to reasonably compensate them for using their own personal device.
Jessica Hart , Owner
Jessica Hart Consulting
Beyond the legal obligation, having a clear BYOD policy protects both sides. It sets expectations about when employees are expected to be reachable, what counts as work communication versus personal use, and what safe device use looks like in a production environment where people are operating equipment.
The simplest version of a BYOD policy does three things: states that the company will provide a monthly stipend for work-related device use, defines what "work use" includes, and makes clear that employees are not expected to respond to work communications outside of their scheduled hours except in genuine emergencies. That policy fits on one page and protects you.
Tip 3: Build a usable employee handbook
Every winery owner has some version of a handbook story. Either they have one that nobody reads, or they know they should have one and keep putting it off. Jessica’s position is that the handbook is worth doing, but only if it is actually accessible to the people who need it.
The handbook does several things at once. It communicates your workplace policies clearly and in writing. It establishes at-will employment, which matters a great deal in practice when a separation happens. And it creates a documented record that employees were informed of your policies, which is the foundation for any enforcement action if something goes wrong.
If you are not going to read it, your team's not going to read it. And so now how are you going to enforce something that you didn't read and they didn't read?
Jessica Hart , Owner
Jessica Hart Consulting
The format matters. A 96-page PDF that lives in an office drawer is not a functional compliance tool. Jessica’s approach for winery clients is to put the handbook behind a QR code that links to a live document she maintains on the backend. Any updates she makes are immediately reflected in what the QR code shows. The handbook is always current, always accessible from the vineyard or the cellar, and employees can pull it up on a phone in seconds when they have a question.
When you update your handbook, make sure managers read it first. Jessica's rule is blunt: if the owner and managers have not read the handbook, they cannot enforce it. A short internal review session when the handbook is updated takes thirty minutes and means everyone is actually working from the same document.
Tip 4: Document coaching conversations simply
A lot of winery owners assume that disciplinary documentation requires formal paperwork, signatures, and a sit-down meeting. That assumption leads to a common problem: coaching conversations happen, but nothing gets written down, and when a situation escalates there is no record of prior conversations.
Jessica’s guidance here is more freeing than most people expect. Documentation does not need to be formal. It does not need a signature. What it needs is to exist somewhere with a date and time stamp.
If you have a coaching conversation with an employee, send them a brief text or email afterward noting what was discussed. If that feels like too much, email yourself. The record exists. That is what matters.
If you are to have a coaching conversation with a team member, just shoot them a text or an email, or even email yourself. You can do something very simple and it doesn't need to be a sit-down conversation, print it out, sign on the dotted line type situation.
Jessica Hart , Owner
Jessica Hart Consulting
The question of employee signatures comes up constantly. The answer surprises people: an employee refusing to sign a document does not invalidate the document. You note “refused to sign” with the date and time, and the record stands.
The most useful coaching documentation is specific: what behavior or issue was discussed, what was expected going forward, and the date it happened. A text message that says "talked to [name] today about clocking in on time, agreed they would clock in by start of shift going forward" is a complete record. It does not need to be anything more than that.
Tip 5: Have a responsible consumption policy
The wine industry has a workplace dynamic that most other industries do not: alcohol is present in the facility, it is part of the job, and both employees and guests are consuming it. That reality requires explicit policies that most small wineries either have never written down or have written in a way that only addresses the guest-facing side.
A complete responsible consumption policy covers both directions. For tasting room staff, it means maintaining current responsible beverage service certifications, knowing how to recognize when a guest has had too much, and having a clear process for handling those situations — including how guests get home safely. For production staff, it means clear rules about what is and is not acceptable before operating equipment.
You don't get to go to sensory or wine tasting and then jump on a forklift.
Jessica Hart , Owner
Jessica Hart Consulting
The after-shift piece is one that wineries often overlook. Shift drinks are common in the industry, and they are not inherently a problem. But what happens after shift drinks matters. Does your winery have a way to get employees home safely if they have been drinking? A Lyft or Uber account for exactly those situations costs very little and protects the business, the employee, and the community.
Jessica recommends including two separate sections in your responsible consumption policy: one for guest service (what tasting room staff should do when a guest shows signs of overconsumption) and one for employees (expectations around consumption before operating machinery, what happens after a shift wine, and how to handle a co-worker who appears impaired at work). The two situations require different responses and should be addressed separately.
Watch or listen to the full episode on YouTube | Spotify | Apple Podcasts.
For more conversations like this, subscribe to Expert Talks and join The Punchdown, InnoVint’s online community for wine professionals.
Frequently Asked Questions about HR for Wineries
Do wineries need an HR manager? +
Wineries are subject to the same state and federal labor laws as any other employer, regardless of size. A dedicated HR manager is not legally required, but someone in the business needs to understand pay and compensation laws, maintain an employee handbook, document workplace conversations, and stay current on changes to labor regulations. For small and mid-sized wineries, an HR consultant who specializes in the wine industry is often a more cost-effective option than a full-time hire.
What HR policies does a winery need? +
At minimum, a winery should have written policies covering pay and compensation (including meal and rest breaks), a BYOD or personal device reimbursement policy, an employee handbook with at-will employment language, a documentation process for coaching and performance conversations, and a responsible consumption policy for both guest-facing and production staff. In California, several of these are legally required rather than optional.
What are meal premium laws for winery employees in California? +
In California, employees who work more than six hours in a day must receive a 30-minute uninterrupted meal break before their fifth consecutive hour of work. If the employee does not receive that break, the employer owes one additional hour of pay, called a meal premium. This applies to winery production staff, tasting room staff, and any other hourly employees in the state. Employees must be completely relieved of work duties during the break.
What is at-will employment, and why does it matter for wineries? +
At-will employment means that either the employer or the employee can end the employment relationship at any time, for any legal reason or no reason at all. Most U.S. states follow at-will employment, but not all — Montana, for example, is not an at-will state. An employee handbook that clearly communicates at-will employment status is one of the primary legal protections for employers when a separation occurs. Without that documentation, disputes about the terms of employment are harder to resolve.
What should a winery's responsible consumption policy include? +
A winery responsible consumption policy should cover three areas: guest-facing protocols (how staff recognize and respond to guests who have consumed too much, including safe transportation options), employee conduct during work hours (rules around consumption before operating machinery or equipment), and after-shift expectations (what is acceptable after a shift, and how the winery supports employees in getting home safely). Both tasting room staff and production employees should receive training on the policy, and managers should know exactly what steps to take if an employee appears impaired at work.